Thursday, August 25, 2016

September 1…On the Nature of a Discipline or Field of Study…Steward of What?



Have you ever thought about the potential for unintended consequences in acquiring disciplinary expertise?  While one might assume that you see the rewards as worth the risks, this might not be the case, as some of you might be in the program more for the post-credential opportunities than for a genuine desire to become an “expert.” How does all of this relate to your situation and also to the current state of Doctoral Education in Education?           

7 comments:

  1. Kurt here...da.kghdak;ashs.lh

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi, it's Jen here. :)

    I think unintended consequences are almost always going to happen while acquiring disciplinary expertise. And, often, isn’t that a good thing? It is through making attempts and testing hypotheses and being open to what comes out of that that we are able to further our own expertise and add to the existing body of knowledge within a particular discipline. Unintended consequences could lead to positive ways of challenging the status quo and causing change. I do think it is necessary to approach the field of education as Ph.D. students by endeavoring to become experts by looking at and studying all three areas Richardson spoke of: Formal knowledge, practical knowledge, and beliefs and misconceptions.

    However, as a practitioner (I know, I know, Kurt, I should start letting go of the self-proclaimed importance I place on that), I see what happens when constant changes are being forced upon teachers and students in the name of improving education when, often, these bandwagon approaches are impractical. It can be frustrating when new approaches developed out of studies are implemented when there is little external validity. And I also would throw out there that one can be an expert as a practitioner without a Ph.D.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Golde, in Doctoral Education in Education, assembles a variety of facts on the make up of Education doctoral candidates. I personally could relate to a variety of these numbers as I was at the middle of my career when I started, I am part-time and paying my own way, and I do not have an undergraduate degree in Education. I was also brought back to school driven by my professional goals as I explored my Master's degree. Yet I will admit that perhaps I am outside of the majority noted in this article, as I stayed on for my PhD as a researcher desiring to influence change. It was here, with this realization I suppose, that I was particularly drawn to Richardson's, Stewards of a Field, Stewards of an Enterprise.

    As 'stewards of education' we have unique responsibilities. We build upon current knowledge as well as identify ways to improve our practice and the practice of other educators. But, as noted by Richardson, we should also recognize when others hold unwarranted beliefs and misconceptions, and when possible, work to change such perceptions. For it is sometimes self-proclaimed 'experts' that hold these beliefs and misconceptions, forget to look beyond their narrow lens, and as a result make decisions with unintended consequences.

    Doctoral candidates in Education, like myself, are in a unique position to try to change opinions, and perhaps even practices, that result in better decisions or decision-making. I do not necessarily desire to be labeled an 'expert,' but I do hope to acquire the expertise necessary to become a steward in my field. Such responsibility cannot be taken lightly, and as such the risk may be well worth the reward.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kiara: I think the fact that education is a field and an "enterprise" in itself brings about unintended consequences of expertise. Following the Richardson piece, the responsibilities of an education PhD don't end after graduation or with research/ teaching post-graduation. I think it can be difficult to maintain formal knowledge, practical knowledge and belief/ misconception management. Particularly with formal knowledge, since there are so many specializations within the field of education, an understanding of the field of education as a whole (however one may define that, if it can be defined concretely, which is debatable in itself) is imperative. Richardson stresses the importance of meta-awareness, or knowing the overall direction of the field to guide future education leaders. Although this is a consequence of expertise in any field, its especially dicey in education because of so many exceptions and specialties in the field. In general, Richardson exposes a lack of cohesion in the field and that can present a host of unintended consequences, not just the few I've named.

    As far as my own plans and my positionality within the field of education, I lean toward the "not so concerned about being considered an expert" side. I feel like the "Doctoral Education in Education" piece paints a discouraging picture of the field, really focusing on its fragmentation. It also illustrates the profile of an "average" education doc student, a profile I don't exactly fit. Perhaps I'm not so phased by it all because being considered an expert isn't as important to me as evoking some kind of change. (But, maybe the expertise is required to bring said change?)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Like Holly, I started both of my graduate programs in order to obtain a credential for my career - however, I'm not sure that I agree with this week's writing prompt suggestion that this professional need negates or is in conflict with a genuine desire to become an "expert" in my field. While I may not yet be as "disciplined" as many of my Doctoral peers, I do not think that that lack of specificity or total immersion in my field of practice at this time should be considered a negative trait. For me, especially as a part-time student, I see doctoral studies to be a (long) path of critical exploration of the ideas and theories that I have been developing as a practitioner in the field of higher education.

    I sincerely hope that my studies do have unintended consequences - because that means that I will have been exposed to new ideas and transformed as an individual as part of my wandering doctoral studies - perhaps in a similar manner to Labaree's peculiar problem of the teacher to researcher transition. And perhaps my initial resistance to the question posed this week, is very much in line with that transition, just as Labaree suggests that teachers making the doctoral transition sometimes resist the transition to research in favor for their lived classroom experiences.

    Golde suggests that this conflict between a researcher identity and a non-academic professional identity resulted in the development of two terminal degrees - the Ed.D and the Ph.D. I struggled to decide between these two programs, but ultimately chose the Ph.D. due to the research emphasis. For me, I am ready to get out of the daily management of problems and solutions at the classroom/individual level and instead, I want to start thinking about those same issues at a theoretical, moral and structural level to implement wide spread change.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ginger here always running late, sorry.

    I have been thinking about this concept of "expert" since last week. I have been wondering how is it possible, is it even possible given the fluidity of the nature of education. I have been given the "expert" label in the past and have been quite uncomfortable with it as I think that content is always evolving. I do not feel that any one individual is or can be an "expert". Thinking to lines of research within my own field there are so many intermingling concepts that sometimes there is a lack of collaboration and how can this lead to anyone being an expert within a discipline. Also, who decides what expert is?

    I absolutely am in love with the concept of unintended consequences and how these found nuggets of delight can actually lead us in directions that were never thought of before. Entering into my program I had one set idea in my mind and within the first semester my ideas had been transformed into a whole new direction to follow that I had not thought was possible.

    I think that on some level we are all resistant to transformation. Sometimes when I am back in a classroom I feel as if I am being perceived as that person who cannot remember the reality of a classroom setting. I sometimes find myself at war within my thoughts of being the art educator and the emerging scholar...

    ReplyDelete