Thursday, August 25, 2016

October 27… Biesta’s Democratic Research



Consider Biesta’s vision of democratic research...? From what you’ve learned thus far, what sort of place do you see for this kind of work in the world of educational research?  Optional: does Biesta seem to have anything in common with Pring?

4 comments:

  1. Jen here -
    I think it is important to be able to talk about education in more than just quantitative ways. Discussions and research should delve more into ideas and an examination of culture. I think it is a bit of a stretch to say that not funding this kind of research is undemocratic though. Yes, it’s necessary. Yes, it should be funded. Yes, it should exist. I even agree that discussion of more qualitative and cultural questions about education should be discussed and debated with all members of a society. What I can’t figure out is if Biesta is arguing for funding of this research or just respect for it and the knowledge that can come from it.

    Biesta is similar to Pring in that they both believe in the importance of the practitioner being a part of the research and the discussion. They also believe that there is quality research that can be gained from research that doesn’t necessarily fit the “gold standard.” Then there’s the whole philosopher/ John Dewey thing they have in common…

    ReplyDelete
  2. The concept of asking, “what it (education) should work for” instead of “what works” to me is vital. Just seeing how the idea of what works is playing out within education does not seem to be working. The “what works” way of thinking tends to omit the practitioner’s role within education and limits their importance. This approach also does not work on so many levels as we have discussed in class in regards to the inability to conduct “true” experimental research within schools due to the many variables involved.

    In order to get at the purpose of educational research there is a need to open up our thinking within the relationships between research, policy and practice as Biesta has written. We need to be able to think of research as a circular concept as opposed to being linear. Unfortunately individuals seem to have a need to see things as an outcome as opposed to seeing an end as a beginning. I see that the idea of a more circular aspect to educational research is becoming more acceptable within academia however policy makers seem to be slower in their acceptance of a less linear line of research.

    I also agree with Jen in that there are similarities between Pring and Biesta..

    ReplyDelete
  3. Warning! Lots of quotes and messy ideas....

    I must admit, part of me really enjoyed this article. It left me with two takeaways overall; educational research is complex and cannot be reduced to only the technical, and Biesta brought some clarity to much of what I think Pring has been conveying. If you'll forgive the structure, I will attempt to summarize my main/favorite points to explain these two takeaways:

    Educational research is just not that simple:
    • "(The) most important reason for the extraordinary advances in medicine, agriculture, and other fields Is the acceptance by practitioners of evidence as the basis for practice." (pg 3) To say that something 'works' in practice could certainly lend weight to the argument that research is ‘valid’, yet an educational researcher may also argue that, "the question for teachers is not simply 'what is effective' but rather, more broadly it is, 'what is appropriate for these children in these circumstances."(pg. 11) And would these circumstances always be the same? I think not.
    • The idea on page 8 of "effective for what?". When Biesta gives the example of a student vs. a patient being two very different things, it brings about a multitude of great points. The biggest for me, you will know what works for a patient when the patient begins to get 'better'. But how do you judge 'better' for a student? Who defines what that will look like, and how in the world could you possibly identify the same 'better' for every student?
    • O.k....now for my FAVORITE. "Research, in short, can tell us what worked but cannot tell us what works." Boom! Drop the mic....No seriously, Biesta touches on the idea of the technical and the cultural being important factors of learning/research. And I think she says it best when she suggests that, 'To see a classroom through the lens of behavioral objectives or through the lens of legitimate peripheral participation can make a huge difference.(...)A key problem with the idea of evidence-based practice is that it simply overlooks the cultural option. It focuses on the production of means for given ends and reduces research questions "to the pragmatics of technical efficiency and effectiveness.' (pg 19)

    Biesta and Pring:
    • Biesta's point on page 3 of the article about finding "what works" shaping legislation that regulates federal research funding. What does this say about Pring's point in Chapter 10? "Educational researchers should not agree to conduct research that conflicts with academic freedom, nor should they agree to undue or questionable influence by government of other funding agencies." (pg 188)
    • Pring's point regarding 'teaching to the test'. When he points out in his excerpt on page 199 that the students have been trained well to "meet performance indicators," yet he also cites that the biggest problem is that "the learners are miserable as sin." Relation to Biesta? See my third point above....If our goal in practice is to synthesize information and build schema , not to just simply memorize, why would we design research to not include the cultural?
    • And as far as Biesta's idea of democratic research? An interesting label I think to use, but I believe if the research lens includes both the technical and the cultural it could lend more voice to quality educational research. While perhaps less generalizable, the results could provide context and support that helps to reach into the realms of true practice. A point, I think, Pring would agree with based on much of what he says along the way, but perhaps best quoted as he cautions about political context, "Standards change as education tries to keep up with changing social and economic challenges." (pg 193) So….why fight so hard to leave the cultural out?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I noted where Biesta defines a democratic society. He says "a democratic society is precisely one in which the purpose of education is not given but is a constant topic for discussion and deliberation" (18). Here, he basically asserts the fluidity of education. It's much easier to quantify and simplify education and "what works" than to deal with the "negotiation" of educational research. Pring warns of the danger of the word "negotiate" in the context of ed research in the ethics chapter. I could have totally missed the boat on this one, but I took this as looking at education as a negotiation with many other factors (ethics included), makes things harder and infringes on the "right to know" Pring considers somewhat of an inherent right.

    I think many people see best practices, evidence based research and the like as things we all have the right to know. We should all have the right to know exactly how many minutes of play a child (every child) needs to work well in school. We should all know what a child (every single child) should eat in order to pass kindergarten. If such things are perceived to be quantifiable (which unfortunately, they are) and the research is available, then people will expect and demand the data. Education is socially constructed and culturally informed, so such cure-all quantifiable findings on human subjects are full of error.

    I'm pretty sure I have a socio-anthropological slant here, but I see the way evidence-based research excludes cultures, practitioners and other important factors, and especially, as both Print and Biesta mentioned, "judgements." There is definitely a place for democratic ed research. I'm struggling because I don't know if I can say the same about evidence-based research.

    ReplyDelete