At the end of Chapter 6, Pring warns us to “beware of the
-isms…”. That said, try to make sense of where you see Pring fitting in,
“-ism-wise.” Feel free to draw on Paul and 702 here (or not).
I'll be honest, I feel very unsure about my blog ramblings... This might just be within my own mind but I found myself pinging back and forth among –isms for this post. I reread the chapter after reading the blog prompt (I think that may have been a mistake) looking for a signpost that might point me toward the –ism I was seeking. After rereading and thinking about it in my congested mind I feel that Pring is Postmodern…or at least my understanding of Postmodern. In his warning to “beware of the –isms” it seems that he is perhaps trying to make us think more deeply about the divisions between qualitative and quantitative. Isn’t Postmodern thinking dealing with how differing concepts are perceived as being dichotomous but in reality they coexist? He writes of how the subjective and objective blur and how there is an infinite amount of realities that exist. Following this line of thinking there needs to be an acceptance that there are multiple ways of thinking and to not think in terms of dualities but rather the similarities. Pring makes me ponder the possibilities of acceptance and cohabitation between qualitative and quantitative. It seems that his argument is that we need to work for understanding and to build upon research. On page 100 he mentions that there is not a long-term research program. In Art Ed we have recently talked about this very idea in terms of researchers not building upon research to create a stronger body of knowledge and how this is a problem within our field.
Honestly, I can’t tell where Pring fits in. He seems to flip flop back and forth between ideas and philosophies. But that could just be me misunderstanding what he is trying to say. Using realism as an example, he seems to begin by critiquing the idea of realism because the idea of “real” is too philosophical to take as actual reality. But then he talks about how there is a certain realness to the world. I just can’t tell. He also talks about the faultiness of common sense because it is a social construction that is always changing, but then he talks about the undeniability of certain aspects of common sense.
The distinctions between the -isms have always bothered me a bit because I see them as a way to try to pigeon-hole people into a certain set of beliefs, when most of us have multiple beliefs that fall into multiple categories. I’ll be interested to hear more about where others in our class would place him, because I truly don’t know where he goes.
Admittedly, Pring's cautionary "beware of -isms" at the end of Chapter 6 caused me to read Chapter 7 before really stepping into my thoughts. But even after this additional explanation, I agree with Jen and Ginger as I am uncertain of where Pring may fit within these "-isms." He seems to waiver between each philosophical lens as he describes them, along with their positives and negatives.
But if I step back and think back to 702, the variety of lenses we may choose to use as researchers to frame our work are vast. Pring didn't even begin to touch on all of those that we identified in 702, he only discussed three with a fourth that I'd never even heard of. It was due to this realization that I paused on my analysis of where he may fit, and instead decided to drive this blog post with a different question (hope that's o.k.!). Is Pring, in his own way, asking us, as researchers, to consider the "-isms" for what they can each bring to the bigger picture when brought together?
In order to really dissect something and then make sense of your perspective on this 'thing,' you must adopt a specific lens to help relay your views. But when we choose to focus on something with one lens, we do loose the perspectives of the others. Pring seems to point this out; while appreciating the need to view something with a philosophical framework, he also cautions that "one should believe only that which has been thoroughly corroborated through (...) critical examination by others." (pg 138) Such a statement leads me to believe that while criticism may seem to discredit what we find through our lens, it can also give it the opportunity to be....more. Consider as he continues with, "today's wisdom might be tomorrow's folly unless one is alert to circumstances which cast doubt on that wisdom." (pg 139)
To put it simply, lenses allow us to see, but no one lens will ever allow us to see the 'big T' truth. Instead, I surmise, when we each examine the same 'little t' truth with our own perspectives, do we not end with a more complete picture? "There cannot be growth of knowledge without criticism." (pg 141)
I agree with Ginger. Thinking about the -isms, I could see Pring falling under the post-modernist/ structuralist category. He tends to question reality a lot and he also questions language a great deal. In the chapter about the -isms, he goes on to point out how subjectivity can leak into the -isms where its supposed to be left out, how global/ societal interpretation can seep into interpretivism and make it less person, etc. In my opinion, he exhibits the characteristics of someone who may deeply question the world as it stands. His stance of not being phased by the -isms also solidifies this. If everything is questionable to him, he would never feel comfortable being associated with one concrete paradigm/ -ism.
I'll be honest, I feel very unsure about my blog ramblings...
ReplyDeleteThis might just be within my own mind but I found myself pinging back and forth among –isms for this post. I reread the chapter after reading the blog prompt (I think that may have been a mistake) looking for a signpost that might point me toward the –ism I was seeking. After rereading and thinking about it in my congested mind I feel that Pring is Postmodern…or at least my understanding of Postmodern. In his warning to “beware of the –isms” it seems that he is perhaps trying to make us think more deeply about the divisions between qualitative and quantitative. Isn’t Postmodern thinking dealing with how differing concepts are perceived as being dichotomous but in reality they coexist? He writes of how the subjective and objective blur and how there is an infinite amount of realities that exist. Following this line of thinking there needs to be an acceptance that there are multiple ways of thinking and to not think in terms of dualities but rather the similarities. Pring makes me ponder the possibilities of acceptance and cohabitation between qualitative and quantitative. It seems that his argument is that we need to work for understanding and to build upon research. On page 100 he mentions that there is not a long-term research program. In Art Ed we have recently talked about this very idea in terms of researchers not building upon research to create a stronger body of knowledge and how this is a problem within our field.
Honestly, I can’t tell where Pring fits in. He seems to flip flop back and forth between ideas and philosophies. But that could just be me misunderstanding what he is trying to say. Using realism as an example, he seems to begin by critiquing the idea of realism because the idea of “real” is too philosophical to take as actual reality. But then he talks about how there is a certain realness to the world. I just can’t tell. He also talks about the faultiness of common sense because it is a social construction that is always changing, but then he talks about the undeniability of certain aspects of common sense.
ReplyDeleteThe distinctions between the -isms have always bothered me a bit because I see them as a way to try to pigeon-hole people into a certain set of beliefs, when most of us have multiple beliefs that fall into multiple categories. I’ll be interested to hear more about where others in our class would place him, because I truly don’t know where he goes.
Admittedly, Pring's cautionary "beware of -isms" at the end of Chapter 6 caused me to read Chapter 7 before really stepping into my thoughts. But even after this additional explanation, I agree with Jen and Ginger as I am uncertain of where Pring may fit within these "-isms." He seems to waiver between each philosophical lens as he describes them, along with their positives and negatives.
ReplyDeleteBut if I step back and think back to 702, the variety of lenses we may choose to use as researchers to frame our work are vast. Pring didn't even begin to touch on all of those that we identified in 702, he only discussed three with a fourth that I'd never even heard of. It was due to this realization that I paused on my analysis of where he may fit, and instead decided to drive this blog post with a different question (hope that's o.k.!). Is Pring, in his own way, asking us, as researchers, to consider the "-isms" for what they can each bring to the bigger picture when brought together?
In order to really dissect something and then make sense of your perspective on this 'thing,' you must adopt a specific lens to help relay your views. But when we choose to focus on something with one lens, we do loose the perspectives of the others. Pring seems to point this out; while appreciating the need to view something with a philosophical framework, he also cautions that "one should believe only that which has been thoroughly corroborated through (...) critical examination by others." (pg 138) Such a statement leads me to believe that while criticism may seem to discredit what we find through our lens, it can also give it the opportunity to be....more. Consider as he continues with, "today's wisdom might be tomorrow's folly unless one is alert to circumstances which cast doubt on that wisdom." (pg 139)
To put it simply, lenses allow us to see, but no one lens will ever allow us to see the 'big T' truth. Instead, I surmise, when we each examine the same 'little t' truth with our own perspectives, do we not end with a more complete picture? "There cannot be growth of knowledge without criticism." (pg 141)
I agree with Ginger. Thinking about the -isms, I could see Pring falling under the post-modernist/ structuralist category. He tends to question reality a lot and he also questions language a great deal. In the chapter about the -isms, he goes on to point out how subjectivity can leak into the -isms where its supposed to be left out, how global/ societal interpretation can seep into interpretivism and make it less person, etc. In my opinion, he exhibits the characteristics of someone who may deeply question the world as it stands. His stance of not being phased by the -isms also solidifies this. If everything is questionable to him, he would never feel comfortable being associated with one concrete paradigm/ -ism.
ReplyDelete