Thursday, August 25, 2016

October 13…Ed. Research and the Question of Quality



Chapters 8 and 9 together raise a lot of interesting questions about just how objective we can hope to be with social science/educational research and, consequently, about the potential worth or these sorts of inquiry. He also discusses action research as a potential way to do work that matters…discuss.

5 comments:

  1. Katherine here - By the end of chapter 8, I was ready to jump into action research as a bridge between "true" research and practical and relevant action. However, my hopes were subsequently dashed when Pring revealed in the next section that action research still won't meet the expectations for publication, and therefore funding, perhaps tenure - and most likely policy making. What's a newly minted PhD to do?

    If your little r research is too closely aligned with meeting teachers’ actual classroom needs, your study risks lacking objectivity and generalization. However, if you veer into big R research, your study may be statistically and politically important, but hardly relevant where it matters most - in impacting educational outcomes.

    Pring's "solution" is to perform quality research, and he outlines 6 best practices that seemingly apply to all research methods: 1) formulate good questions, 2) provide the answers to the questions so clearly that evidence can be gathered to prove it wrong, 3&4)publish for peer review (but make sure to get published in the right journals), 5) Don't forget to think like a philosopher to conceptualize your study well in the first place, 6) use the methods that meet the question

    Sure, these are all good practices. Any good researcher (whether teacher/action researcher or big R research should use these. But do they really help us identify good from better from best? We've veered back into the land of subjectivity and a general lack of clarity in how to determine what good educational research is.

    If Pring’s point is that we should be proud of the big R or little r research we are doing as long as we do it well, then great. It seems to me that he is frequently reminding the reader to be aware of false dualisms – yet to a certain extent this awareness serves little purpose other than to continually put the reader/researcher on-edge in questioning validity and purpose. I suppose that is a good thing, that this line of philosophical questioning would lead to well thought out, purposeful, meaningful and ethical studies. A philosopher's mindset is needed for research - I guess that is why we are getting PhD's, huh?




    ReplyDelete
  2. Jen here...
    Action research is something practitioners have been doing for years. In the past five years or so, data-driven research has been popping up more as a part of action research in schools. This added component allows teachers to add a quantitative perspective to the very qualitative way in which they have done research. In social sciences, especially education, a combination of both seems necessary. A lot of the chapters seemed to talk about the lack of generalizability of action research because each classroom, each student, and each teacher has its own respective values, which make the research most purposeful for that situation. However, certain aspects of action research can be used as methods and ideas that may work in other situations. It is through action research that much of the pedagogy surrounding special education has emerged. The same could be said for facilitative instruction and the emphasis being placed on student engagement right now in education.

    Much of action research is intuitive for practitioners as they are always striving to find better ways to teach. However, theory to stimulate action research often trickles down from university researchers to K-12 settings. Theorizing is just as important because it allows teachers to think about teaching in ways they haven’t before. The improvements in special education, facilitative instruction, and student engagement could also have gotten their start from theorizing academics as well. I think it is through a balance of theoretical educational research and action research that “work that matters” can be constructed.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I myself have yet to conduct action research; however, it's something I'm very interested in. I was also a little let down while reading to see how action research isn't as valued as other forms of research. I think it comes down to our commitment (or lack thereof) to the research itself and our values. We all have to eat and tenure is the goal for many of us (not necessarily mine though). Money/ tenure/ stability aside, it's still possible to do the research that needs to be done, to empower the folk that are often subject to our research and truly make a difference. I believe that even small participation in such research can yield some big (significant) results. I like to think of higher education in general as a duty. If we are fortunate enough to obtain advanced degrees, we should be more than willing to take part in things like action research. Action research has the potential to relate to practitioners and other stakeholders outside of the ivory tower. How could we exclude the people outside of academia (even if just a little bit) and call ourselves researchers and change agents?

    I think the bigger goal here would be to change the system so that all research is valued just as much others, but in the meantime, we have to make our own change in our own smalls ways.

    ReplyDelete
  4. In reading the replies thus far I start to question why is it that action research is not seen as "real" research? Perhaps it's my background but for me I think of it as another method for conducting research. Perhaps it is not seen as being as rigorous since often (but not always) it is a method used by practitioners in a K-12 setting. My mind then jumps to professors who use action research within their practice, are those with a PhD who use action research not grounding their work in theory? I think that if practitioners were explicit as to their theoretical underpinnings the work might be perceived as having more rigor. I'm starting to feel as if I'm going in circles.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have written this blog post three times, so please forgive me if my ramblings make more sense to me than anyone else. And so sorry for the length....

    Research can be defined in a variety of ways, but in the interest of a quick search; research is, according to Siri, "the systematic investigation into and study of materials and sources in order to establish facts and reach new conclusions." Yet when we try to discern just how to go about conducting research that fits this definition, well that tends to get a little swampy....Maybe not so much if you find yourself in a discipline that is a bit more cut and dry, like medicine (or is it really that cut and dry?). But in the disciplines of education, where I live, the world of research is definitely swampy. Swampy in the sense that people are different and complex, no two situations are ever going to be completely the same, and in the context of where the observed occurs...that too can add a whole different element.

    There are a tremendous amount of criticisms when it comes to the research in our field, and perhaps this presents some hurdles for some of us as we work to find our place. We could argue that as 'experienced' researchers and the outsider looking in, we could bring a lens of validity and objectivity that yield credible work. Yet what do we loose when we observe as the outsider? What are we missing when we only see a small part of a much larger context? "The physical and social contexts in which an activity takes place are an integral part of the activity, and the activity is an integral part of the learning that takes place within it." (pg 147). Could action research and ‘teacher researchers’ be the key to navigating the ‘swampy’?

    "The criticisms of educational research referred to at the beginning of this book have led to skepticism about the value and validity of educational research which does not involve the teachers themselves. (.....) Therefore, there is a renewed interest in teacher and action research." (pg 158) If we do indeed go back to the beginning of the book, on page 10 Pring lists his four biggest points of criticism of educational research. The first two points, identifying ‘what works’ and connection from professional practice, appear to be addressed through action research and the use of ‘teacher researchers.’ Action research is, by design, a form of inquiry that allows practitioners to improve their practice. Yet when we get into the idea of fragmented pieces and poor quality, we find ourselves again in the swamp. This leaves me to wonder, should action research be considered a part of a larger piece as opposed to a stand-alone inquiry? In other words, can action research serve to inform the research instead of replace it? And would such inclusion eliminate some of the criticisms that educational research currently faces in relation to objectivity, validity, reliability, and/or applicability?

    I can see the value in what Pring presents, and I hesitate to drop the idea simply because it doesn't fit the 'mold' just right. This is put best perhaps as I quote a text from 702, "Research does not construct evidence - people do." (pg 50, Rallis and Rossman, 2012) in relation to the new, "Research is the servant of professional judgment, not its master." (Pring, pg 164)

    ReplyDelete