Thursday, August 25, 2016

December 1…The Roles of Theory in Educational Research



What light have the authors in Anyon shed on the issue of how theory should operate in our empirical research projects? Are there any new confusions that have sprung up in the wake of reading this book?

3 comments:

  1. While I admit that I have only read the intro, epilogue, and chapter 3 of Anyon thus far - she has, in short, given me a different lens in which to view educational research altogether. A lens that I like very much. Pring, where we started, appears to support the use of theory, but cautions that those in power (politicians and lobby groups that advise them) are often against its use as they look more for 'what works'. But I then find myself taken with Anyon, as she speaks to theory’s purpose and importance in research. "Without a theory that paints the whole picture, that fills in the spaces and lines forming the substance of the painting, only a fragmented image is produced." (pg 16) And doesn't Pring caution us against the fragmented?

    "Theory should help us deepen our research process and raise the level of our studies' meanings, significantly extending and enriching the yield of our empirical work." (pg 5, Anyon) In Anyon’s text, Theory and Educational Research, each researcher uses theory for various purposes – yet, as Anyon suggests in the quote above, I would argue that each use adds support to the significance and validity of their work. "These writers rely on a stretch to connect the messy local to larger political, economic, and cultural formations; to deconstruct and reimagine." (pg 181, Anyon)

    But if it allows us to make such connections….now I’m wondering….was Pring actually cautioning us to understand how powerful the use of theory can be? ‘What works’ is often serving the majority I would venture….does the potential use of theory to give those that are usually overlooked a voice, and a powerful one, scare those in politics? Does it paint too vibrant a picture, show too much of a pattern, indicate too assuredly that they need to start paying attention?

    I guess I’m ultimately left with the realization that the theory we choose for our research can either hurt or help. But we should not use theory to help craft what we will say and do. I understand that we must consider the ‘required or expected’ standards that will be used to judge our educational research. But perhaps it’s o.k. to embrace the swampiness of our discipline sometimes too, especially when it provides voice to those that need one. The idea that what we do can help to provide others voice, especially to those that otherwise may have gone unheard, is inspiring. While I know that I want others to read my research, and for what I write to matter....I know now that perhaps I also need to ask myself, matter to whom?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Like Holly I have only read the assigned reading for this evening thus far. The concept of research being emancipatory in nature with an outcome of awareness within individuals to seek/create change makes me excited for research. I enjoy diving into critical social theories and find them to speak to me sometimes. We are constantly using theoretical frameworks but not always aware of them. At this point as emerging researchers we are beginning to think more deeply and to have the ability to label our frameworks and others’ theoretical frameworks in order to better understand underlying meanings that are being made. This emerging awareness will build in order to enable us to better situate our research.

    I’m not sure if this answers the question but someone recently suggested that I take a certain course in order to immerse myself within a particular theory and that by doing so it would help me to find my methodology within my research. I think that this suggestion will help me to better answer the idea of how theory will operate in my own empirical research project..

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really liked what Anyon says in the introduction about theory - there's a line where she basically says that going in the field without theory is like your work laying on the ground lifeless, without a heartbeat. I think about chapter 3, the chapter I'm presenting on today in particular. Dumas shares about his observation of a school boarding hearing and how a community leader was defeated by some benign and dismissive comments of an official, trying to shut down his call for a re-structuring of a stratified school division and its inqeuitable allocation of resources. The theoretical concepts presented in the chapter that Dumas uses to analyze what happened gives a completely new (and constructive) spin on the occurrence and sets the reader up to automatically think about ways to approach and think about what happened. If someone would have been in the very same situation (a community leader looking to bring change to a troubled area, with the powers that be offering little to no help or compassion) with a lack of theoretical knowledge, he or she may be more likely to grow discouraged and give up. Theory, in this sense, can be a form of empowerment.

    This hits home for me, as someone who was very skeptical of the importance of theory at one time. I didn't get to read the epilogue, but I'm looking forward to it (Michelle Fine wrote it and she also wrote Framing Dropouts, an ethnography I really really enjoyed reading).

    ReplyDelete